Page 31born-digital extractionTh :.: AH:CJ ll1d l ·t 111 \ Fdi. l!J io J c:011li1n1c<l to g1•111•r,1t..: llt.:W ;JSlClJll;JUt (;Fl) f-1iry IJlcs with tile rinony111011s rcH•l;,tinn from "Mr. X", who hL·,.irtl the Apt>II,>-I l ,htrn11:iuts d escribe Hthre•: di::,· ::h:.!:J•.•\! s h:-u:l,:-i•.•:5 tl1;,t \.V' •n-• pac i11~ them ::ic r-i,: ; th.: :;urfc1cc of the moon. '' The best answer l.'o thi.; f:tbrir.ltivn is in a I! tler from ;--: ASA Assistcnt Administrator for Legislative Afiairs Rob(;rt F'. Allnutt, to Congr<)s;:nan Bob Casey, dated January 29, 1970: ''Conversation between the Apollo 11 c,·ew :ind ~·Jission • Cont,ol were released live during the entire Apollo 11 mission. There were betwel)n 1000 and 1500 rep resentati\·es of the news media present at the Houston News Cl)nter listening and observing, but not one has suggested that NASA withheld any news or conversations of this nature." The evidence is clear. There is, out of all the dozens of "reports of astronaut UFO sightings", no residue of authentic cases, no 20:o or 5% or even 0.01% of " true UFOs" behind all the "noise". My research is compelling in its conclusion: afler fifteen year3 of manned space voyages including space stations and landing on the moon, spacemen have brought back not a: shred of evidence-verbal, phpto• graphic, or otherwise-for the existence of extraterrestrial spacecraft, or "UFOs". That" evidence, if it exists at all, must be sought elsewh ere. The performance and standards of conduct of the UFO groups and of UFO writers cannot be cause for optim;sm that such evidence, if it exi;;ts. will bP. recognized and correctly ~valuated. The lesson of the "astronaut UFOs", then, teaches us nothing about UFOs, but a lot about UFO investigators. Scientific Study nf Unidentified Fly ing Objects (Condon Report}, Bant_ am Edition, 1969, Chapter 6: Visual Observations :\lade bv Astronauts/ Franklin E. Roach. Pag;s 176-209, with bibliography through 1967. Good bal"k;;round m:itNial including unpublish<'d 1 ·alitl solutinns to a numbL'r of c;isrs. Incorrect solution to Gemini- :--~ I case. lnad..-4uat<- anal_ .-~b and u1,j11stificd encinr,;l)nH•nt ot f:,,r,;i ni-1 ',- ca.,,·. Th i: £,!;;,: o/ Uc:ul,l_\', b} fl:,-n,·k and Vallee. Hl'nry H,•:,:1 ll'ry & Co., 1975. Pa;:l· G:!,6-1 111 ::i S1.·ctit>11 cnllt·ci ..The Sl.'!,·nlbl~ :it \\',,.-1;". \,L• fi,id tl1 c phony Fa1u·..tt li.,t. Li.; L l;a~ incorn:cl dales and 111a11y lli;.:hi.:; nul ,if ~•H1ur11cc. On J uly I, 1~7Li. lk J . .-\lk-11 Hyne k rc,:i,".\"£•d 111 y ,,,·it.lean, and cndors,·d it, anrl n•p11 :l'.11,·ci I hr. F'awcctt li, t. which he ;·L'port,·d tl1,1t lw inr:luded in his book as a ru,i1.>sity Olily. That is, just becau~e ht ' pre,t'nted it a~ fact to thousands ot' ro:adt'rs '.\·as no reason for anyone to concl11 dl.! he thought it was true. This appallingly irresponsible attitude towards rules of e\·idcnce seems to in fer.t the whole UFO field. Sightings by 26 A stronauts Co11iirm: UFOs Spied 011 Sl:ylabs (sic) Jla11y Other Space Shots-U FOs Watch Every tlo\'e NASA ;\Jakes, Say Astronauts Who Were Tailed on Space Shot, " National Tattler", March 17, 1974. This is an embellished version of the same Fawcett fantasies. Weekly tabloid newspaper "conformed to the highest standards of modern reporting. Tattler and its staff are dedicated to total, truthful coverage..." In fact, staffer Robert Abborino made no effort to check any of Fawcett's outrageous claims. UFOs Past, Prese11t and Future, by Robert Emenegger, research by Alan . Sandler. Ballantine, 1974. Chapter 15, "Na:;a", pages 100-106. Extensive transcripts of space communications cover up the fact that Sandler carefuily selected evidence and must have knowingly omitted information which would have explained . many cases. An excellent photo section is included. UFO Report, People Press, 1975. "NASA Hiding UFOs From You", by Robert D. Barry, pages 4-10. Barry is associated with Carl Mcintyre's fundamentalist Christian group, and is one of the wilder UFO writers. Even the mass media has learned to disregard his fictional descrip tions of non-events. Here, he explains "why NASA called in the CIA to keep these photos secret", without explaining how , in that case, he got copies. He uses the forg.cd Gemini-7 photo proudly. Flying Saucers-Here and ,Vow', by F'rank Edwa rd,,, Lyle Stuart. >iew York. 1967. Astruna~1t iar.ta~il's w h()lly ur in part creatrd in the forti le (and unlimil l)d by w,il ily) mind o f ·11,-11-;man' l·'ra11 l- Ed1\Jrd,; :ire iound on p:1ge$ t :L l HO. an<1 l !l 'i. Tltrnu i,: h s11d1 entriL'$ :i j,>11 rnalis111 stud t"n l can trace thl· adual i::r,,wth of the myth. , \ /'l:U Hui/din, :\l.1rd1-:\pril 1970 6:! and l-'dJru.iry 197:; a11<! nthc•,~- T l11, nyi11g saucer club llt'w. ,;let tL•r b·,l t:. pi fit s the dlsn•gard for i1:1p,,.·ti:tl i11ws1i;,:atio11 o f cvid~•nc~ whid1 prtH·id1)d the climatr in wh:ch the mylh ot' --astronaut liFOs " co11IJ g-101\· and tluu nsh. Th e Star, :Vfan.:h ~- 1976. pa;:,• 7. Sequence or headlines: On the front page, ''Astronauts Say: We Saw L:FOs in Space". On pai::e 7, --Tc-iJ Astronauts Con firm: We spotted l\\'O UFOs". lll the article, ;\!cDi·:itt ta!k5 oi his UFO, and Cooper discusses his exper:ences as a fighter pilot in Germany-and makes 110 mention of the space UFO associated with his name. The headlines, as can be expected in such a newspaper, are deliberately misleading. SAGA magazine, May 1970: Classified TOP SECRET-Apollo Astronauts Reported Two UFO Sightings, by Beckley and Salkin, p. 13 rr: Complete story of Apollo-12 UFO;. plus enough false information to "discredit" the true explanation. Quotes "space expert Gary Henderson", another active spreader of the myth. Refers to long-discredited stories of "secret dead Russian cosmonauts" probably created by F tank Edwards. Houstvn Post, Nov. 30, 1975. page 1D: "Just One Astronaut Claims Seeing UFO ", by Jim ;\laloney. 1his sensible and sane investigation (i\lcDivitt stuck to his story) clearly did not excite the national news media and was relegated to the obscuri ty of a local newspaper. Science and .\lechanics, June 1969. Cover Story: "This UFO was photographed by astronaut Gordon on Gemini 11 flight" (the co\·er photo shows a tremendously enlarged out of focus image of a piece of insulation floating a f.:w inches in fron t of the camera). Page -1-1, Lloyd '.\.lallan: ··.-\re liFO Space Crews Spying on ou r Astronauts?" Descriptio n of the late L. ~lallan's inter\'iews on Ge mini-l ;. provides some new informaLion but cements some old misconce ptirrns. Also embellishes Condon Report "unknowns". Lockhced-~.-\S.- \ Contract ;\ .-\ S 9 -5 191 (.\larch 19 70), ·'T1:ch:1kal Report: L'nid1.•11tified Vi,;uJI Ph1.•11<1mena ...\ssoc;ated wilh Sp:icl' fli:,:ht''. F . HL•atty and J. R:.iron. Di s<.: tb :ic•s the fr,1i,:1ne11ts ~<',· 11 :111d photographt'd on ,\ pol!•J· 12, and traces them t,> spacc,cr:ift effct·r;;.